Daily horoscope, zodiac signs, compatibility and astrology
ZodiacSign.ro
Choose language
ZodiacSign article

Tropical and steel zodiac: where the difference comes from

Tropical and steel zodiac: where the difference comes from

If you read that “you’re Aries” in one place and “Pisces” in another, it’s not a typo: it’s possible that the two sources use different zodiacs. Western astrology usually uses tropical zodiac, while Indian astrology uses steel zodiac. The difference between them is currently about 24 degrees, which is almost a whole sign.

The article explains where the difference comes from, what is the prediction of the equinox, what are the constellations of the signs, why Ophiuchus appears periodically in the news and what to choose if you are curious to find your mark in both systems.

Tropical Zodiac: Related to Seasons

The tropical zodiac starts from the spring equinox, the moment in March when the Sun crosses the celestial equator north. That point is defined as 0 ° Aries and the 360 ° circle is divided into 12 30 ° signs. Being linked to the seasons, the tropical zodiac moves with them: The sun enters the Aries around March 20th-21st each year.

It’s the system used by modern Western astrology and almost all the horoscopes in the press and the Internet, including those on our website.

Steel Zodiac: Star bound

The steel zodiac anchors the signs at fixed stars, i.e. at the constellation background. Indian astrology uses several variants of this system, most commonly being ayanamsa Lahiri. Ayanamsa is the difference, in degrees, between the two systems.

Why is it different: Preparedness of equinox

The Earth’s axis is not fixed: it rotates very slowly, like a dredge, in a cycle of about 25 800 years. The phenomenon is called the prediction of equinox. The consequence is that the point of spring equinox moves back to the background of the stars with about 50 seconds of arc per year, i.e. about 1 ° every 72 years.

About 2,000 years ago, when Greek-Roman astrology fixed the signs, the beginning of the Tropic Aries coincided roughly with the beginning of the constellation Aries. Since then, the equinox has moved. Today, ayanamsa Lahiri is about 24 °, so the “tropical” sun in the Aries is in the area of the constellation Pisces.

Tropical zodiac (Western) Steel equivalent approximately
Aries (approx. March 21 – April 19) mostly pices
Leo (approx. July 23 – August 22) cancer
Capricorn (approx. December 22 – January 19) mostly Sagittarius

Around 80% of people have a different solar sign in the steel system than the tropical one, but not every day changes; those born in the last days of a tropical sign may remain in the same sign. To know for sure, it takes a calculation with the exact date.

Constellations versus signs

One thing that causes a lot of confusion: zodiac signs are not constellations. Signs are equal areas of the ecliptic circle of 30 °; constellations are groups of stars of very different sizes. The constellations that the Sun travels through are, in fact, 13, not 12: between Scorpio and Sagittarius passes and Ophiuchus. Sometimes a wave of articles “zodiac of 13a,” but Western astrology does not define the signs after constellations, but after equal division of ecliptic. That’s why Ophiuchus is not a new sign in this system.

Moreover, the official limits of constellations established by the International Astronomical Union in 1930 are uneven: The sun sits in Virgo for almost 45 days and in Scorpio only 7 days.

Which system is “correct”?

None is “correct” or “wrong” in the scientific sense, because both are conventions of a symbolic system. Western astrologists claim that the tropical zodiac, linked to the seasons and the Earth-Sun relationship, has better symbolic meaning. The Indians claim that fixed stars are the natural landmark. Each tradition has its own rules of interpretation, and their mixture usually causes confusion.

What it means to you

  • If you read Western horoscopes, use the tropical sign, the one in the usual calendar.
  • If you’re interested in Vedic astrology, look for a steel computer with specified ayanamsa (usually Lahiri).
  • If you found different results, check what zodiac each source uses.
  • Do not mix interpretations from one system with positions from the other.

To find your ascendant in the tropical system, use the computer on the site; the calculation steps are in the dedicated guide. For zodios data limits, see the article on zodios data.

A little history: who discovered the precedence

The precession was observed in antiquity by the Greek astronomer Hiparh in the third century BC, which compared star positions with older observations. Later, Ptolemy, in the third century AD, described in his works a zodiac related to the equinox, meaning a tropical zodiac, and Western astrology retained this choice. India’s tradition anchored signs to the stars instead. The two systems therefore began to move away, slowly, year after year.

Example: Sun on April 1

On 1 April, the Sun lies in the tropical system at approximately 11 ° Aries. If you drop an ayanamsa of about 24 °, you get a longitude of about 347 ° in the steel system, which is about 17 ° PICES. Therefore, a person born on 1 April is Aries in the western horoscope, but Pisces in the Vedic. For the 15th of July, the tropical sun is around 23 ° Cancer; decreasing ayanamsa is about 29 ° Gemini, that is to say the limit with Cancer. Border cases of this kind show why the time and place of birth matter in the steel system as much as in the tropical one.

Age Aquarius and precedent

Precession is also the reason they talk about astrological “epochs.” The 25 800-year cycle, divided into 12, gives epochs of about 2 150 years, and the passage of the equinox point through the constellations of Pisces and Aquarius fueled the idea of an Age of Aquarius. The proposed data varies for centuries and the constellations have no precise limits: therefore there is no date accepted by everyone. It’s a cultural story, not a measurable astronomical event.

How you check the difference yourself

  1. Take the date of birth and find out the tropical position of the Sun in an ephemeral or computer.
  2. Decade ayanamsa (about 24 ° currently Lahiri).
  3. If the result goes below 0 °, add 360 °.
  4. Divide by 30 and find out the steel sign.

The result depends on the choice of ayanamsa, because there are several (Lahiri, Raman, Krishnamurti, Fagan-Bradley). The differences between them are in the order of grade to one degree.

What to remember, briefly

The difference between the two zodiacs is not an argument between “truth” and “mistake,” but a point of origin difference: the seasons for the tropical system, the stars for the steel system. If you use one system and read written interpretations for that system, everything remains coherent. Problems only occur when you mix sources.

Why Romanian sites use the tropical

Most horoscopes published in Romania, as in the rest of Europe, follow Western tradition. For the regular reader, this means that the sign in the astrological newsletter and in the mobile applications are the same. If you need the steel version, look explicitly for “Vedic astrology” or “jyotish.”

Frequently asked questions

Has my zodiac changed?

Your tropical zodiac remains the same. If you read that “has changed,” the source uses either the steel system or a definition after constellations.

What is ayanamsa?

It is the difference in degrees between tropical and steel zodiac. The value depends on the choice and increases by about 1 ° to 72 years.

Why do Romanian horoscopes use tropical zodiac?

Because the Western astrological tradition taken over in the European press uses this system.

Is it true there are 13 zodiac signs?

The sun passes through 13 constellations, but the astrological zodiac has 12 signs, defined by equal divisions of the ecliptic, not by constellations.

Astrology is not science. The astronomical data (precedence, constellations) are verifiable; symbolic interpretations are not.

Uploading comments...
Tontea Ioan Alin, editor of ZodiacSign.ro
Author

Tontea John Alin

ZodiacSign.ro · passionate about astrology from 2020

Article read and approved by the editor prior to publication. Astrological interpretations are symbolic and indicative, not scientific facts or safe predictions.

Share